The Quran from Orientalists Point of View

The Quran from Orientalists Point of View

A Critical Approach to the Link between the 'Historicity of Understanding' in Philosophical Hermeneutics and Feminist Readings of the Quran"

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 University of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran
2 Assistant Professor in the Department of Islamic Studies at the University of Tabriz
10.22034/jqopv.2026.12545
Abstract
Purpose: This article seeks to answer how the connection between the historicity of understanding and feminist readings of the Qur'an is formulated, and whether this connection is epistemologically justified. The study examines the foundations upon which feminist interpreters have relied in re-reading Qur'anic verses on women's rights and gender equality.

Method: Employing a critical-comparative method, the authors first examine the foundations of the historicity of understanding in philosophical hermeneutics, particularly in Heidegger and Gadamer. They then illustrate its application in the views of prominent feminist theorists—Amina Wadud, Fatima Mernissi, and Nasr Hamid Abu Zayd. Finally, drawing upon authentic Islamic sources including classical exegesis, Qur'anic sciences, and the methodologies of distinguished commentators, they present comprehensive critiques of this connection.

Findings: Absolute historicity of understanding conflicts irreconcilably with the Qur'an's foundational pillars: divinity, inerrancy, eternity of the guiding message, and decisive rulings. This approach leads to interpretive relativism, collapse of textual authority, infinite fluidity of meaning, and self-refutation. Practically, it leads the feminist scholar to conflate description with prescription, deny fixed rulings, and impose personal preference upon the divine word.

Conclusion: In contrast to the extremist feminist approach, the article proposes "Renewal within the Framework of Tradition"—distinguishing the context of revelation from the eternal message and historical descriptions from permanent prescriptions—enabling a just re-reading of gender equality concerns without falling into relativism.
Keywords


Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 13 October 2026

  • Receive Date 13 October 2026